Sometimes, Lorna Grinnell-Moore gets the phone slammed down on her. Commonly, she has to listen to the most outlandish false claims and, once, she has a memory of being verbally abused.
"There's always going to be people of that sort, unwilling to accept information, and it feels like a failure."
However, this is standard for the day job for Lorna. She's been calling households whose young ones have not received the measles, mumps, and rubella vaccinations in an effort to convince them to get immunised. Inadequate uptake of vaccines mean the infection has taken hold in the city, mostly affecting children below the age of ten.
A Forward-Looking Approach
Lorna's been here before - she was part of a team of health service staff that completed thousands of telephone contacts in just three months after an increase in measles infections in late 2023 impacted numerous youngsters. These discussions by themselves led close to a thousand once reluctant guardians and adolescents to take up the offer vaccination.
Within a London borough, which is grappling with a measles surge, authorities are examining cities such as Birmingham for methods to control it. Fifty cases have been identified in the current year, predominantly affecting young children, some of whom have been required inpatient care.
Leveraging Veteran Staff
During Birmingham's 2023 outbreak, some ex-healthcare workers were returned to service, as occurred previously. In this instance, though, as opposed to vaccinating people, they were tasked with convincing people to receive them.
Their mission involved placing follow-up calls to parents and patients in the under-25 bracket to discuss what was stopping them obtaining the jab against a disease that can have grave complications - encompassing brain inflammation and vision impairment and, on rare occasions, death.
Presently, Lorna, a vaccination program lead, and a nursing team have been enlisted to restart the phone campaign as infections are increasing again.
Navigating Difficult Conversations
The job is far from simple. It requires a specific methodology which combines listening closely and seeking to appreciate the person on the other end.
"After I grasp their point of view, I can then address their queries," states Lorna. "Sometimes they listen, and other times they state they don't want to hear more."
"The goal isn't to act like an authoritarian figure."
If people are prepared to continue the conversation, Lorna is confident she can then ease their apprehensions or doubts about the vaccine and aid in reducing them.
Guidelines and Assistance
A policy limits calls to three attempts. Another is not to leave messages due to potential confusion. Staff members fluent in a number of different languages, such as French, Italian, Arabic, and Urdu, can help with making calls when the primary language isn't English.
Complementing the telephone campaign, the collaborative outbreak team also runs an information campaign and engages with community organizations.
Measurable Impact
The work across the city has had a significant effect. Over the course of 2024, thousands of additional immunizations were administered – and the overall vaccination count was 20 percent greater than the previous year.
In particular, there had been lower vaccine uptake among specific communities, such as Roma, Eastern European, South Asian, and Black communities.
Language barriers were addressed by boosting the information available in a range of languages, including publishing QR codes linked to videos outlining the positives, paired with standard poster campaigns.
Doctors' Surgeries Adapt
A number of primary care clinics have also initiated their own call-and-recall work. One of those is Hall Green Health, which has advanced the approach by offering GP appointments to parents who are hesitant so they can address their questions in person with a GP.
"In my view, society has become lax about the true severity of measles," states Dr. Sonia Ashraf, a partner.
She says there are various reasons that lead to reluctance. The fact MMR contains pork gelatine is a frequent issue, but this is relatively easily resolved by providing the alternative of the jab that is gelatine-free.
Debunked studies from the 1990s linking the MMR vaccine to autism also often arises, while some parents also worry about the volume of recommended jabs given to youngsters. By the age of four, they will have been offered immunization on half a dozen occasions.
"Certain guardians wonder the reason for multiple jabs or believe their kids are robust enough these diseases," adds Ashraf. "We spend time going through the evidence with them – misinformation is widespread out there."
Funding Challenges and Future Outlook
The call-and-recall support has since been made available elsewhere. Yet, owing to financial constraints, it is something that can only be done in a constrained manner. Recently, vaccination levels fell once more to pre-2024 levels, leaving the city still well below the 95% threshold needed for population-wide resistance.
Even with periodic rises in infection, there has been nothing like the number of cases that were seen in the past outbreak, when diagnoses surpassed five hundred.
The head of vaccinations, says the outreach approach "proves highly effective" but "not a silver bullet" and needs to be paired with additional measures. In an ideal scenario, he notes it would be used more but additional funding is required.
Current funding for the calling system is secured until the conclusion of the current fiscal period.
The Wider Context
Birmingham is not the only area to use this technique. A number of other places have undertaken analogous programs.
However, improving rates countrywide has remained a struggle. At present, fewer than 85% of children have had both required shots by the age of five.
"This is a genuine difficulty," notes a specialist. "The causes of vaccine hesitancy are complicated and diverse. An element frequently ignored is ease of access. For